Is Collagen in Skincare Just a Gimmick? Here’s What Tallow Does Instead

Let’s talk about something that’s absolutely everywhere right now: collagen. It’s in powders, pills, protein bars, face creams, serums, even your morning coffee (yep, really). Skincare brands love to throw the word around—it sounds scientific, luxurious, and, let’s be honest, a bit magical.

But here’s the million-pound question: does rubbing collagen on your skin actually do anything?

Well... not much.

Why Collagen Creams Don’t Do What You Think

It’s easy to get swept up in the promise of “collagen-boosting” creams that promise firmer, younger-looking skin. It sounds amazing, right? Slather a cream on and your fine lines disappear like magic?

Unfortunately, it doesn’t quite work like that.

Collagen molecules are actually too big to sink into your skin. So when you apply a collagen cream, those molecules mostly just sit on the surface. You might feel a bit of short-term plumping or smoothing (which is nice!), but it’s not going deep enough to stimulate real collagen production or make long-term changes to your skin.

Ingestible collagen, like powders or supplements, might help—there’s some early science suggesting benefits there. But putting collagen on your skin? That’s more about smart branding than true results.

What Your Skin Really Needs to Make More Collagen

Here’s the thing: if you want to boost your skin’s natural collagen production, you need to use ingredients that actually stimulate your own skin to do the work. Think vitamin C, retinoids, peptides—ingredients that your body recognises and can use to spark change from within.

So, when you see “collagen cream” on the shelf, what you’re usually looking at is a standard moisturiser with a buzzword slapped on the label. It’s not bad—it just might not be doing what you think it is.

Let’s Talk About Tallow: The Underdog That Works

Now here’s where things get interesting. You’ve probably heard us go on about tallow before—and with good reason. It’s not the flashiest ingredient on the market (definitely not as trendy as snail slime or diamond dust), but it works.

Tallow is rendered animal fat, and it’s packed with skin-loving nutrients like vitamins A, D, E, and K. More importantly, its composition is incredibly similar to our skin’s natural oils (aka sebum), which means your skin knows exactly what to do with it.

One brand putting tallow back on the map is FatCow Skincare. We’ve gone all in on this ancestral ingredient—ditching the fillers, fragrance, silicones and fluff in favour of formulas that are rich, bio-compatible, and made to genuinely support your skin.

Why Tallow Is Different (and Better)

Unlike collagen creams that promise the world but can’t make it past your skin’s barrier, tallow feeds your skin with the kind of nutrition it can actually use:

• Vitamin A for cell turnover and elasticity (hello glow)
  
  

• Vitamin D to help calm and repair irritated skin
  
  

• Vitamin E for antioxidant protection and resilience
  
  

• Vitamin K to help reduce redness and inflammation
  
  

• Plus CLA and palmitoleic acid—natural anti-inflammatory and antimicrobial compounds that support a happy, healthy skin barrier
  
  

Tallow doesn’t just sit on your skin—it gets to work. It helps lock in moisture, soothe dryness, calm flare-ups, and leave your skin feeling strong, soft, and supple.

No gimmicks. Just real, old-school nourishment.

Real Skincare, No Marketing Hype

Let’s be honest: collagen skincare might make for a great ad campaign, but if you’re looking for long-term, meaningful change, you need ingredients that work with your skin—not just look pretty in a jar.

Tallow is one of those ingredients. It’s rooted in tradition, backed by biology, and designed to support your skin naturally—not smother it in silicone or distract it with synthetic scents.

At FatCow Skincare, we’re proud to be part of the movement that’s ditching the hype and going back to basics. Skincare should feel good, yes—but it should work, too.

And tallow? It really does.

Back to blog